Conservation

Update on the Maehyang-ri Tidal Flat Blue Carbon Project: University Birders’ Shorebird Survey

In late February, our team visited the Hwaseong Wetlands FNS, and were very concerned to see that extensive structures were being built across the nationally protected Maehyang-ri tidal flat as part of a blue carbon project. Concerns were expressed, and advice was sought from independent experts, with all responses highlighting the expected negative impacts. Although it was suspected that some species (like Terek Sandpiper 뒷부리도요 and of course gulls) might even roost on these new structures, many shorebird species were considered unlikely now to be able use this area for roosting on neap tides – especially larger species like the globally Endangered Far Eastern Curlew 알락꼬리마도요. This is largely because most shorebird species need an open skyline when roosting, presumably in order to detect and to avoid potential predators. In addition, concerns were also expressed about the damaging method of construction including the use of heavy machinery; and the likely low level of climate benefit to be accrued by this approach. These concerns were all expressed in the clear and important understanding that, “Climate change and biodiversity loss (as well as pollution) are part of an interlinked triple planetary crisis the world is facing today. They need to be tackled together if we are to advance the Sustainable Development Goals and secure a viable future on this planet” (United Nations website).

These initial expert concerns about the likely impacts on shorebirds and the low efficacy of the blue carbon gains were communicated clearly to decision-makers and multiple stakeholders. They were also followed by expert commentary from the Wadden Sea – cited as the basis for the project design – that observed that, yes, similar approaches had been undertaken in some (much larger) areas of coastal tidal flat in the past, but that in more recent decades more natural processes have generally been preferred. Further insights on how similar measures would be evaluated in the context of the German-Dutch-Danish Wadden Sea. were provided by WWF Germany.

Unfortunately, following an indication to suspend the project temporarily, the decision was taken to continue work on the construction of the 1m high, stone-filled wall and to leave all of the tall wooden poles in place. A large trust deficit meant that funds that were to be provided for shorebird surveys to be conducted by local NGOs together with researchers contracted by the blue carbon project were not taken up.

We are therefore very grateful to members of the University Birding Clubs of Korea who, following some correspondence with us, independently organised two surveys of shorebirds in the Maehyang-ri Tidal Flat Wetland Protected Area and Hwaseong Wetlands Flyway Network Site: Kwon Soonho and Kim Jin A on April 29th; and Lee Gun Hee, Kim Jin Young, Jung Minju and Lee Ju Hyeok on May 11th.

The survey included repeat counts and an assessment of use / avoidance of the tidal flat structures by different shorebird species.

Selected images from the April survey © Kwon Soonho and Kim Jin A.

As summarized by Mr Lee Juhyeok (known as Andy Lee to many in the birding community),

“We initially planned to conduct five surveys from late April through May. Unfortunately, two surveys had to be canceled due to heavy rain, and another was canceled due to the absence of a volunteer driver. As a result, we were able to complete two surveys in total — one on April 29th and the other on May 11th.

During the first survey, we were still refining our methodology and approach to data recording, so the documentation is less detailed. After that session, we revised our data collection process. In particular, we began referring to individual structures by specific identifiers:

  • Structure A refers to the long, 1-meter-high wall.
  • Structures B refer to the rectangular transplantation plots (from which fencing had already been removed).

Summary of Observations:

  • Small waders appeared largely indifferent to the B structures, likely due to the absence of fencing.
  • Mid- to large-sized waders, however, tended to remain farther out toward the sea and appeared to avoid structure A, maintaining a noticeable distance.
  • While we regret not being able to conduct more surveys under varied tidal conditions, we hope these two sessions still offer some insight and are of value.”

Count data are available on Excel, and we are proposing to conduct further counts together in August and September during the southward migration period.

More information will be posted about this research this summer. Please contact us if you would like to participate in or support this survey effort (e.g., through driving researchers, or supporting expenses). Thank you.

More from Conservation

70년 탐조인생 마지막 바다새를 찾는 피터 해리슨씨의 꿈은 …

By 김영걸 1983년 세계 최초로 바다새들에 대한 필드가이드북 “Seabirds: An Identification Guide”를 출간하여 전세계적으로 바다새 탐조 열풍을 불러일으킨 영국 탐조가 피터 해리슨씨가 지난 5월 29일 인천공항에 도착했다. 본인의 책에 소개된 434종의 바다새 중 그간 유일하게 관찰하지 못한 뿔제비갈매기(Chinese Crested Tern)를 … read more

부산 가덕도 공항 예정지에서 실시한 조류충돌 세미나

3월 9일, 부산 가덕도 대항 마을에서 열린 세미나 소식. 예정된 공항 건설이 진행되면 평화로웠던 포구와 주민들의 보금자리는 완전히 매립되고 만다. 공사는 올해 말 시작될 예정이라고 한다. 세미나는 현재 진행 중인 법정 도전을 위한 준비의 일환이었다. 새만금을 비롯한 전국 각지의 활동가들과 … read more

Science지 2월호-새만금-국내 언론보도(2025/02/21)

Science 2월호에 실린 서한과 관련한 국내 언론의 기사 링크를 아래에 올립니다. 서한 집필진이 배포한 국내 보도자료에는 새만금 현장 활동가이신 오동필님의 사진을 함께 실었으며, 특히 이화여자대학교 생명과학과 교수이자 생물다양성재단 이사장인 최재천 교수님께서는 “수라 갯벌은 세계유산으로 지정된 지역에서 불과 7km 밖에 떨어져 … read more

가창오리 Sibirionetta formosa에 관한 주요 사실

글: Dr 나일 무어스, 새와 생명의 터 상임대표 2025년 1월 28일 최근 언론은 2024년 12월 29일 대한민국 남서부에 위치한 무안에서 발생한 끔찍한 항공기 사고에서 충돌한 조류는 가창오리(Baikal Teal Sibirionetta formosa)인 것으로 보도하였다. 이는 양쪽 엔진에서 피와 깃털이 발견됨으로써 확인되었으므로 비행기가 … read more

공식 발표: 연천 임진강 철새이동경로 네트워크 서식지 등재

 나일 무어스  보존활동 나일 무어스, 새와 생명의 터 대표 동아시아-대양주 철새이동경로 파트너십(EAAFP)이 2024년 10월 11일, 연천 임진강을 철새이동경로 네트워크 서식지 “EAAF156” 으로 공식 등재했다는 소식을 알리게 되어 기쁩니다. 2024년 10월 22일의 EAAFP 사무국 홈페이지 발표문에 실려 있듯이, 연천 임진강 철새이동경로 … read more